When I was an undergraduate at Tel Aviv University, the law faculty adjusted exam grades by adding the same number of points to everyone's score. The policy may have changed since then. But does an equal increase benefit everyone equally?
Consider a class with an average of 50. I score 80; another student scores 40. Adding ten points brings the average to 60, my grade to 90, and the other student's to 50. Yet the ratio has changed: my original score was twice theirs; my adjusted score is only 1.8 times as high.
A proportional increase offers another approach. Raising every grade by 20 percent produces the same average of 60, but gives me 96 and the other student 48. The original ratio survives.
The flat increase preserves the absolute gap between students, but narrows the relative one. Compared with the proportional adjustment, students above the mean receive fewer points, while those below it receive more. In that sense, higher-scoring students "give up" points for lower-scoring classmates - a small exercise in distributive justice.
The dividing line is the class average. Below it, the flat increase is more generous; above it, the proportional increase is. What appears to be a simple correction therefore contains a choice about fairness: should we preserve the distance between students, or their relative standing?
Apparently, at my law school, being below average had its advantages.